Ask a creative for an idea today, and there’s a good chance you’ll get a name.
“Oh, I know this TikToker who does exactly that.”
“You should check out this creator on Instagram.”
“I love this person’s content. We should work with them.”
And just like that, the creative conversation is over. We’ve found our person. Apparently, we’ve also found our idea.
Somewhere along the way, we’ve confused casting with creativity.
When Did the Who Replace the What?
The rise of the creator economy has fundamentally changed how brands approach social media. And much of that change has been positive.
Creators understand communities, cultural nuances, platform behaviors, and audience expectations in ways traditional advertising often struggles to replicate. They bring authenticity, credibility, and entertainment to brand communications.
But something strange has happened in the process.
Instead of asking what we should create, we’re increasingly asking who we should create it with.
The creative brief has become a talent search. The brainstorm has become a scroll through Instagram. And the big idea? Often reduced to finding someone who’s already doing something interesting and paying them to do it with a product.
We’ve gone from creating ideas for people to finding people who already create ideas.
That’s not necessarily bad marketing. But is it really creative thinking?
Creators Aren’t the Problem. Our Dependence on Them Is.
There’s an important distinction here.
A creator can absolutely be the inspiration for a brilliant idea. Their personality, community, unique perspective, or signature format can unlock opportunities that would otherwise never exist.
But there’s a difference between building an idea around a creator and using a creator instead of having an idea.
One requires imagination. The other requires a contact list.
And when the entire creative proposition is “let’s get this person to do their thing with our brand,” we have to ask ourselves what value the creative agency is actually adding.
Are we creating something new? Are we challenging conventions? Are we finding unexpected connections between brands and culture?
Or are we simply renting somebody else’s creativity?
The irony is that the more brands rely on creators to supply the ideas, the more their content risks looking like everything else in the feed.
Different brand. Same creator. Same format. Same joke.
Bring Back the Idea.
None of this means going back to traditional advertising, forcing scripted brand messages onto creators, or pretending agencies know audiences better than the people who have built them.
Quite the opposite.
The best social-first creativity should come from the intersection of a strong strategic insight, an original idea, and the unique talent of the people bringing it to life.
Creators should make ideas better, stranger, more culturally relevant, and more entertaining. They should challenge creative thinking, not replace it.
The question shouldn’t simply be “Who should we work with?”
It should be “What could we create together that neither of us would have thought of alone?”
Because finding the right person is a skill.
Giving them something worth creating is creativity.